How to deal with child being left out
What to Do When Your Child Feels Left Out| Banner Health
There may be nothing more crushing to a parent’s heart than hearing that someone is being mean to your child. Or, even worse, that your child is being left out by their peers. It may even conjure up memories of your own childhood traumas.
While bullying and excluding others aren’t something new, today’s social interactions don’t just take place in person. There’s a whole social network online to navigate—which means lots of new ways for children to feel excluded and let down. Suddenly, kids are a little more particular about who they hang with and social activities become a little more awkward and uncomfortable.
As kids traverse these changes, it doesn’t matter how well-adjusted or well-liked they are, they are bound to feel left out at some point in time. Perhaps they’ve become one wheel too many in a friend group, or maybe they’re being ignored on the playground or left out of a social event. Whatever the case, your child may be a victim of what’s called relational aggression.
What is relational aggression?
According to the National Association of School Psychologists, relational aggression “refers to harm within relationships that is caused by covert bullying or manipulative behavior,” such as socially excluding someone from a group, spreading gossip and rumors or giving someone the “silent treatment.”
“Social exclusion is quite profound and can take many forms,” said Adeola Adelayo, MD, a practicing psychiatrist with Banner Behavioral Health Hospital. “It’s pervasive not only in the humans but also in other animals such as chimps. We are social animals; we want to get along and fit in—especially when we’re younger—but maintaining peer relationships during this time can be fraught with complications.”
So, what can you do as a parent?
As a parent, you’re often left wondering what to do to help. Should you stay out of it or step in and help? Dr. Adelayo shared some things parents can do to help their child overcome exclusion and build lasting friendships.
Ways You Can Help Your Child Cope When They’re Being Excluded
1. Listen intently
When your child comes home from school and shares they are being left out, try not to react too quickly (I know, it’s hard to control mama/papa bear mode when someone comes after your child). Encourage them to talk and then let them talk—don’t interrupt, criticize or diminish what they’re sharing with you.
2. Validate feelings
When they’re done sharing, validate their feelings and demonstrate you understand how they feel. Affirm that they have the right to be safe and feel secure.
3. Keep it in perspective
Remind them that every child goes through this—whether they are “popular” or not. If applicable, ask them if they’d like to hear about your own personal encounters as a child navigating similar circumstances. Let them know that friendships will change a lot over the years—especially those tween and young adult years. Remind them of the healthy relationships and friendships they do have with others; those people in their lives who bring them joy and see their worth.
4. Make home a comforting and safe space
Home is where the heart is. Your child may feel very isolated right now and school may be distressing at the moment. Make home a safe haven for them. Tell and show your child that they are unconditionally loved and valued by their family. While you aren’t the same as having a friend, remind them that you will never leave them out, and they can always count on you.
5. Establish other connections
Encourage your child to branch out and play/socialize with other kids. They may just discover other people with the same interests. Help them foster those friendships through playdates and scheduled activities. By broadening their circle of friends, they’ll develop confidence and feel comfort on those days when they’re feeling left out in other areas.
6. Find healthy coping skills
Help your child find healthy ways to cope, such as journaling, crafting, listening to music, exercising, playing sports or volunteering. Finding an outlet can help them deal with the stress and anxiety they are experiencing and may even help them to develop connections with like-minded people.
7. Set boundaries with others
Help your child learn how to stand up for themselves in an assertive and respectful manner. Develop ways they can communicate their distress and acknowledge the inappropriate behavior. Practice statements like, “Stop it. I don’t like what you are doing.” Remind them to seek support from their teacher, the school and you, as their parent, if the relational aggression continues.
8. Know when to seek help
While you want your child to learn to solve their own issues, if your child is being physically threatened or harmed at school, let the administration know.
If relational aggression has your child depressed and anxious and it’s affecting their day-to-day life, please contact one of Banner Health’s trusted child and adolescent specialists for help. Never ignore the impact this type of behavior can have on your child.
If your child is contemplating suicide or self-harm, contact the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255.
Additional Resources:
- Help Your Tween Navigate Their Emotions
- Teen Dating: Four Tips for Parents
- Parenting Teens: Five Ways to Promote a Healthy Body Image
- Could You Be a Lawnmower Parent?
Behavioral Health Parenting
Join the Conversation
Six Ways to Help Your Child Deal with Social Exclusion
The mom of a third-grade girl sits in my office, her face buried in her hands. Through muffled sobs, she tells me that she’s at a loss. She’s tried everything to help her daughter repair her friendships at school—arranging coffee dates with the families of the other girls, meeting with the teacher and school director, and even trying to organize a group sleepover to get the girls together—but nothing has made a difference. Her daughter is on the outs with a peer group she formed in preschool, and this mom feels powerless to help.
Her daughter is the victim of what’s called relational aggression. For reasons she might never understand, her three close friends have built a new alliance and excluded her. They taunt her, spread rumors about her, and leave her out of their activities, encouraging others to do the same. They seem to have no remorse, while she experiences anxiety, nightmares, and academic difficulties.
Relational aggression can occur in person or online and can include gossiping, spreading rumors, public humiliation, alliance building, and social exclusion. Unlike physical bullying or verbal aggression, relational aggression can be difficult to spot. Recess, passing periods, lunch, and the walk to and from school are hotspots for relational aggression, but the damage can also be done outside of school, often under the radar of adults.
Advertisement XMeet the Greater Good Toolkit
From the GGSC to your bookshelf: 30 science-backed tools for well-being.
Unfortunately, this girl—and her mother—are not alone. According to statistics compiled by The Ophelia Project, a national nonprofit with expertise in relational aggression, 48 percent of students in grades 5-12 are regularly involved in or witness relational aggression, and students between the ages of 11 and 15 report being exposed to 33 acts of relational aggression during a typical week. The proportion of youth who experience cyberbullying is estimated to be as high as 40 percent or more.
As I detail in my book No More Mean Girls, being the victim of relational aggression can come with some long-term consequences. In fact, relational aggression is said to be as painful as physical blows, and its negative effects can last for years to come. Children who experience relational aggression are more likely to be absent from school, perform worse academically, be socially isolated, and exhibit headaches and stomachaches, behavioral problems, eating disorders, suicidal ideation, substance abuse, symptoms of depression and anxiety, loneliness, and low self-esteem. No wonder that mom is concerned!
But there is good news: Parents can help their kids deal with social exclusion by teaching them coping skills and empowering them to seek healthy friendships. While your natural instinct may be to get the school involved, communicate with the parents of other kids, and jump into problem-solving mode, what kids need most is support, empathy, and space from the problem. Try some of these strategies adapted from No More Mean Girls.
Watch for the signs
Given that kids experience feelings of shame and embarrassment when being victimized, they don’t always come forward right away. Many wait until they feel like they’re falling apart before they reach out for a lifeline. To that end, it helps parents to watch out for the red flags that a child is experiencing relational aggression:
- Anxious or nervous behaviors
- Frequent physical complaints, such as headaches or stomachaches, particularly before school or social events
- Talking about sitting alone at lunch or playing alone at recess more often than not
- Appearing withdrawn or depressed
- Changing academic performance
- Acting out in class or at home, or even turning the tables and acting as the bully
- Talking about having no friends or being “hated”
- Talking about death or engaging in self-harm (cutting)
- Sleep disturbance: Difficulty falling asleep, difficulty staying asleep, frequent nightmares, or excessive sleeping
- Changing eating habits
Once you see these signs, you will want to check in with your child or the school to see if relational aggression may be causing them.
Use conversation starters
One reason kids hesitate to come forward when dealing with relational aggression is that it’s difficult to discuss. They don’t want their parents to think that they’re incapable of making friends.
Open and honest communication with kids is essential during middle childhood and the tween/teen years. They need to know that parents will listen without judgment and provide unconditional love and support. To get in the habit of deep, distraction-free conversations, create a pack of conversation starters to use when you have downtime together. It helps to start a weekly ritual of quiet conversation and hot chocolate (or some other cozy treat).
Examples of conversation starters might include:
- Something funny that happened this week was…
- If I could escape anywhere for just one day, it would be…
- Something hard that I had to deal with this week was…
- I wish my friends…
- Something you don’t know about me is…
- My favorite way to spend a day off is…
Taking turns pulling conversation starters for each other from an envelope helps you connect in a low-stress environment and helps your child open up about difficult topics.
Make a friendship tree
Kids are usually tasked with making a family tree at some point in school, but making a friendship tree is a great way to help kids realize that they have many different friends in life. Just as family extends beyond the people living in your home, friendships blossom in a variety of contexts.
Start the tree with the friends your child knows the best (even the ones she doesn’t spend much time with), but cue your child to think about friends made in sports, through religious organizations, in extracurricular classes, or even at your local park. In filling the branches with friends from a wide variety of settings, girls learn to focus on the positive relationships in their lives. When kids see that they have more friends than the people sitting at their lunch table, they are empowered to strengthen those other branches and even add new ones by trying new clubs, sports, or activities.
Create a personal billboard
When friends constantly leave a child out, that child internalizes the message that he or she is unlikable or not a good friend. It’s important to help kids tap into their inner strengths and recognize that they are good friends to others.
Give your child a small poster board and ask her to think about her positive qualities. This can include anything from cracking funny jokes to creating cool games to giving great compliments. Next, explain that billboards are used to draw attention to things and showcase the highlights. Have your child put her name in the center of the poster board and ask her to create an eye-popping billboard that includes her positive traits. This is a great way to help kids recognize and focus on their strengths.
Problem-solve together
This essay is adapted from No More Mean Girls: The Secret to Raising Strong, Confident, and Compassionate Girls (TarcherPerigee, 2018, 336 pages)
One thing I see over and over again is that parents are determined to “fix” things for their kids. When kids finally find the strength to come forward and share their feelings and experiences, parents whip out their phones and begin texting other parents, emailing the school, and even reaching out on social media to garner support. Kids tend to retreat inward again in response.
A better strategy is to problem-solve with your child. The first step is to really listen to what your child is saying. Ask follow-up questions to make sure you understand. Empathize with your child. Ask your child to help you jot down notes so that you can remember the specifics to share with helpers. Communicate that you understand how painful the situation is and that you are there to help and provide support.
Next, move into problem-solving. It’s important to brainstorm possible solutions together to empower your child to take action. In doing this, you teach your child how to cope with future similar situations. Try to brainstorm four or five possible solutions, and talk about the pros and cons of each. Make an action plan together.
Create a coping kit
Whether your child is left out from one or two social events or experiences social exclusion frequently at school, he or she needs to have coping skills available to deal with the emotional upheaval. I encourage parents to tuck a pack of coping cards into the child’s backpack, as it can be difficult to remember what to do when under stress. Every child is different, so it’s important to create these cards with your child, but you can try a few of these to get started:
- My touchstone at school is (fill in the blank). I can ask this person for support.
- Deep breaths help me feel calm. Breathe in (count four), hold (count four), breathe out (count four).
- Remember this friend (fill in the blank) in another class to hang out with at recess.
- Tensing and relaxing my muscles helps me release stress. I can start with my hands.
It’s perfectly normal for kids to experience ups and downs with friendships, but a pattern of social exclusion (or other acts of relational aggression) should be addressed with the classroom teacher and the school administration. Take notes when your child shares specific stories and capture screenshots if any of this behavior occurs online. If you do notice symptoms of anxiety or depression that interfere with your child’s daily living (school, after-school activities, sleep, eating), it’s best to seek an assessment from a licensed mental health practitioner.
Parents really are not powerless to help their kids recover from social exclusion, but they do need the right tools. By acknowledging feelings, finding solutions together, and helping children tap into their own resources, parents can support their kids through this agonizing experience and ultimately prepare them to face any future adversity with more confidence.
Greater Good wants to know: Do you think this article will influence your opinions or behavior?
Submitting your rating
Topic 6. Features of the development of a child left without parental care.
- General features of the development of a child left without parental care.
- Causes, manifestations and consequences of emotional deprivation in a child left without parental care.
- Types of "disturbed attachment".
- The concept of "grief and loss" in the life of a child left without parental care.
I. General features of the development of a child left without parental care. nine0014
Peculiarities of mental development of children brought up outside the family, without parental care (in orphanages, orphanages and boarding schools) is an urgent problem of our time.
The pace of development of such children is slower compared to children brought up in a family. Their development and health have a number of negative features that are noted at all stages - from infancy to adolescence and beyond.
Inmates of closed children's institutions of each age level are characterized by specific and different sets of psychological traits that distinguish them from peers growing up in a family. nine0017
The specificity of the development of children brought up in closed children's institutions indicates that many properties and qualities of their cognitive sphere and personality are preserved throughout the entire considered age period, revealing themselves in one form or another. These include features of the internal position (weak focus on the future), emotional flattening, simplified and depleted content of the image of the Self, reduced attitude towards oneself, unformed selectivity (bias) in relation to adults, peers and the objective world, impulsiveness, unconsciousness and lack of independence of behavior , situational thinking and behavior and much more. nine0017
Psychological characteristics of children brought up in an orphanage, children's home and boarding school, and the characteristics of their communicative activity are interconnected. The development of communication in children is largely determined by how it is organized and carried out by an adult. Interaction with an adult should provide the child with the formation of age-appropriate forms of communication, its content.
Deprived of parental care, they, as a rule, have a need for communication, and therefore, under favorable conditions, a relatively quick correction of their development is possible. Thus, deviations and delays in the development of the psyche and personality of a child brought up in an orphanage, an orphanage and a boarding school that arose in the early stages of ontogenesis are not fatal. nine0017
Briefly formulating the characteristics of children left without parental care, we can draw the following conclusions:
figurative, abstract-logical, verbal, etc.), low erudition, etc. The reasons for low intellectual development can be different: from a violation of the normal functioning of the brain, to the absence of a normal educational environment (pedagogical neglect). Lack of due attention to the intellectual development of the child can lead to a serious backlog in learning. nine0017
2. Joint activities and communication of children with peers. In the game, children are less attentive to the actions and states of their partner, often do not notice resentment, requests, and even tears of their peers at all. Being close, they play separately. Either everyone plays with everyone, but joint games are mainly procedural in nature; there is no role-playing interaction in the game; even being included in some general plot, children act on their own behalf, and not on behalf of a role-playing character. According to the operational composition (according to the actions performed), such an activity is very similar to a role-playing game, but in terms of the subjective, psychological content, it differs significantly from it. Contacts in the game are reduced to specific appeals and comments about the actions of a peer (give, look, move, etc.). nine0017
3. The problem of gender identification of pupils of boarding schools. Stereotypes of female and male behavior enter self-consciousness through the experience of communication and identification with representatives of the same sex. In orphanages, children are isolated from these orientations. Preschoolers are already well aware of their gender, they strive to assert themselves as a boy or a girl, in this they differ little from children brought up in a family. However, qualitatively gender identification has significant differences. If children in a family are identified with their parents, close relatives and peers, then children deprived of parental care are identified, first of all, with their peers, i.e. boys and girls in the group. nine0017
4. Problems of the moral development of the personality of pupils. Problems of moral development begin from primary school age and manifest themselves most often in theft, irresponsibility, suppression and insult of the weaker, in a decrease in empathy, the ability to sympathize, empathy, and, in general, in a lack of understanding or rejection of moral norms, rules and restrictions.
5. Socialization of orphans. Under the difficulty of socialization, experts understand a complex of difficulties for a child in mastering a particular social role. Mastering these roles, a person socializes, becomes a personality. The absence of normal contacts for an ordinary child (family, friends, neighbors, etc.) leads to the fact that the image of the role is created on the basis of conflicting information received by the child from various sources. nine0017
6. Problems of emotional and volitional development of pupils. The greatest difficulties and deviations from the normal development of the personality of children from orphanages are noted by all researchers in the emotional and volitional sphere: in violation of social interaction, self-doubt, reduced self-organization, purposefulness, insufficient development of independence (“personality strength”), inadequate self-esteem. Violations of this kind are most often manifested in increased anxiety, emotional tension, mental fatigue, emotional stress. nine0017
Despite the presence of some common features that characterize the mental development of orphans, it should be borne in mind that, as a subject of psychological and pedagogical support, they represent a rather arbitrary group, internally differentiated. In fact, the only reason to unite the inmates of orphanages is the deprivation syndrome. At the same time, each child has his own individual history of orphanhood, his own experience of relationships with adults, his own special character of personal development, which in not all cases can be qualified as a lag or mental retardation. Due to these circumstances, the psychological and pedagogical support of the mental development of a child left without parental care can only be of an individual nature. nine0017
The fact that the child develops under conditions of deprivation also has a great influence on the child's personality.
II. Causes, manifestations and consequences of emotional deprivation in a child left without parental care.
Psychological problems in the development of both children and adults most often arise in connection with their experience of deprivation or loss. The term "deprivation" is used in psychology and medicine, in everyday speech it means the deprivation or limitation of the ability to meet vital needs. nine0017
Depending on the deprivation of a person, various types of deprivations are distinguished - maternal, sensory, motor, psychosocial, and others. Let us briefly characterize each of these types of deprivations and show what effect they have on child development.
Maternal deprivation . The normal development of a child in the first years of life is associated with the constancy of the care of at least one adult. Ideally, this is maternal care. However, the presence of another person who takes care of the baby when maternal care is impossible also has a positive effect on the mental development of the baby. A normative phenomenon in the development of any child is the formation of attachment to an adult caring for the child. This form of attachment in psychology is called maternal attachment. There are several types of maternal attachment - reliable, anxious, ambivalent. The absence or violation of maternal affection associated with the forcible separation of the mother from the child leads to his suffering and negatively affects mental development in general. In situations where the child is not separated from the mother, but does not receive maternal care and love, there are also manifestations of maternal deprivation. In the formation of a sense of attachment and security, the bodily contact of the child with the mother, for example, the opportunity to cuddle, feel the warmth and smell of the mother's body, is of decisive importance. According to the observations of psychologists, children living in unhygienic conditions, often experiencing hunger, but having constant physical contact with their mother, do not develop somatic disorders. At the same time, even in the best children's institutions that provide proper care for babies, but do not allow physical contact with the mother, there are somatic disorders in children. nine0017
Maternal deprivation forms a child's personality type, characterized by unemotional mental reactions. Psychologists distinguish between the characteristics of children deprived of maternal care from birth and children forcibly separated from their mother after an emotional connection with the mother has already been established. In the first case (maternal deprivation from birth), a steady lag in intellectual development, inability to enter into meaningful relationships with other people, lethargy of emotional reactions, aggressiveness, and self-doubt are formed. In cases of a break with the mother after the established attachment, the child begins a period of severe emotional reactions. Experts name a number of typical stages of this period - protest, despair, alienation. In the protest phase, the child makes vigorous attempts to regain the mother or caregiver. The reaction to separation in this phase is predominantly characterized by the emotion of fear. In the phase of despair, the child shows signs of grief. The child rejects all attempts to care for him by other people, grieves inconsolably for a long time, can cry, scream, refuse food. The stage of alienation is characterized in the behavior of young children by the fact that the process of reorientation to other attachments begins, which helps to overcome the traumatic effect of separation from a loved one. nine0017
Sensory deprivation. A child's stay outside the family - in a boarding school or other institution is often accompanied by a lack of new experiences, called sensory hunger. A depleted habitat is harmful to a person of any age. Studies of the conditions of speleologists who spend a long time in deep caves, crew members of submarines, Arctic and space expeditions (V.I. Lebedev) testify to significant changes in communication, thinking and other mental functions of adults. The restoration of a normal mental state for them is associated with the organization of a special program of psychological adaptation. For children experiencing sensory deprivation, a sharp lag and slowdown in all aspects of development is characteristic: underdevelopment of motor skills, underdevelopment or incoherence of speech, inhibition of mental development. Another great Russian scientist V.M. Bekhterev noted that by the end of the second month of life, the child is looking for new experiences. A poor stimulus environment causes indifference, a lack of reaction of the child to the reality surrounding him. nine0017
Motor deprivation. A sharp limitation of the ability to move as a result of injury or illness causes the occurrence of motor deprivation. In a normal situation of development, the child feels his ability to influence the environment through his own motor activity. Manipulating toys, pointing and asking, smiling, screaming, making sounds, syllables, babbling - all these actions of babies give them the opportunity to be convinced from their own experience that their influence on the environment can have a tangible result. Experiments with offering infants various types of movable structures showed a clear pattern - the child's ability to control the movement of objects forms his motor activity, the inability to influence the movement of toys suspended from the cradle forms motor apathy. The inability to change the environment causes frustration and associated passivity or aggression in the behavior of children. The limitations of children in their desire to run, climb, crawl, jump, scream lead to anxiety, irritability, and aggressive behavior. The importance of physical activity in human life is confirmed by examples of experimental studies of adults who refuse to participate in experiments associated with prolonged immobility, despite the proposed subsequent rewards. nine0017
Emotional deprivation. The need for emotional contact is one of the leading mental needs that affect the development of the human psyche at any age. “Emotional contact becomes possible only when a person is capable of emotional consonance with the state of other people. However, in an emotional connection, there is a two-way contact in which a person feels that he is the subject of interest of others, that others are in tune with his own feelings. Without the appropriate attitude of the people surrounding the child, there can be no emotional contact.” nine0017
Experts note a number of significant features of the appearance of emotional deprivation in childhood. So, the presence of a large number of different people does not yet fix the emotional contact of the child with them. The fact of communicating with many different people often entails the emergence of feelings of loss and loneliness, with which the child is associated with fear. This is confirmed by observations of children brought up in orphanages, who show a lack of syntony ((Greek syntonia with sonority, consistency) - a feature of the personality: a combination of internal balance with emotional responsiveness and sociability) in relation to the environment. Thus, the experience of joint celebrations of children from orphanages and children living in families had a different effect on them. Children deprived of family upbringing and the emotional attachment associated with it were lost in situations where they were surrounded by emotional warmth, the holiday made a much less impression on them than on emotionally contact children. After returning from guests, children from orphanages, as a rule, hide gifts and calmly move on to their usual way of life. A family child usually has a long holiday experience. nine0017
III. Attachment. Types of broken attachment.
The question of how to find a common language with an adopted child and build a trusting relationship with him worries almost every foster parent. And this question is not easy. After all, a child who enters a new family has, as a rule, a negative emotional experience of relations with close adults, separation from them. Some children have experienced neglect and even abuse by adults. All this cannot but affect the building of relationships with members of the new family. To better understand what is happening with such a child and how to help him establish a full life, it is useful to turn to scientific facts. nine0017
Manifestations of attachment
Attachment is formed in babies from about 6 months. The first target is the child's guardian, most often the mother. Later (after 1-2 months) the circle expands, it includes the father of the child, grandparents and other relatives. To a person who is the object of affection, the baby turns for comfort and protection more often than to other people, in his presence he feels calmer in an unfamiliar environment. The following signs indicate that an attachment to a particular person (parent) has formed:
- the child responds with a smile for a smile;
- is not afraid to look into the eyes and responds with a look;
- seeks to be closer to an adult, especially when it is scary or painful, uses parents as a "safe haven";
- accepts the consolations of parents;
- experiences age-appropriate separation anxiety;
- experiences positive emotions while playing with parents;
- has an age-appropriate fear of strangers. nine0004
Stages of formation of attachment
Formation of parent-child attachment goes through a number of successive stages:
- Stage of undifferentiated attachments picked up by another adult. This period is also called the stage of initial orientation and indiscriminate targeting of signals to any person - the child follows his eyes, clings and smiles at an arbitrary person. nine0004
- Stage of specific attachments (7-9 months) – at this stage primary attachment to mother is formed and consolidated. The baby protests if he is separated from his mother, and behaves restlessly in the presence of strangers.
- The stage of multiple attachments (11-18 months) - the child, on the basis of primary attachment to the mother, begins to show selective attachment in relation to other close people. Nevertheless, the mother continues to be the main figure of attachment - the child uses her as a "safe base" for his research activities. If we observe the behavior of the baby at this moment, we will see that, no matter what he does, he constantly keeps his mother in his field of vision, and if someone obscures her, he will definitely move so that he can see her again. nine0004
If a child lacks attention, warmth in relationships, emotional support, then he develops attachment disorders. These include the formation of unreliable types of attachment. Psychologists conditionally identified the following types:
1. Anxious-ambivalent attachment . In children, such a violation manifests itself in their experience of anxiety and feelings of insecurity due to the fact that the parents showed conflicting or too intrusive behavior towards them. These children themselves behave inconsistently - they are either affectionate or aggressive. They constantly “cling” to their parents, looking for “negative” attention, provoking punishment. Such attachment can form in a child whose mother shows insincere emotions towards him. For example, by not accepting the baby, the mother is ashamed of her feelings for him and deliberately demonstrates love. Often, she first confirms the need for contact with the child, but as soon as he reciprocates, she rejects intimacy. In another case, the mother can be sincere, but inconsistent - she is either overly sensitive and affectionate, or cold, inaccessible or even aggressive towards the child without objective reasons. As a rule, in such cases it is impossible to understand the behavior of the mother and adapt to it. The child strives for contact, but is not sure that he will receive the necessary emotional response, therefore he often worries about the availability of his mother, “clings” to her. nine0017
2. Children with avoidant attachment are rather withdrawn, distrustful, avoid close relationships with other people and come across as very independent. Parents of such children showed emotional coldness with them in communication; were often unavailable when their participation was needed; in response to the appeal to them, the child was driven away or punished. As a result of this negative reinforcement, the baby learned to no longer show his emotions openly and not to trust others. To avoid negative feelings and protect themselves from unpredictable consequences, such children try to avoid closeness with others. nine0017
3. The most unfavorable type is disorganized affection . Disorganized attachment is typical for children whose emotional needs were not met by their parents or whose parents reacted inadequately to them, often showing cruelty. If such a child first turned to his parents for emotional support, then in the end such appeals made him shy, discouraged and disoriented. This type of attachment is typical for children who have been subjected to systematic abuse and violence and have never had an attachment experience. nine0017
Clinical early childhood psychiatry defines certain criteria for attachment disorder (ICD-10). Psychiatrists believe that the onset of a clinical attachment disorder is possible from the age of 8 months. They refer to pathology as a dual type of attachment - an insecure attachment of an anxious-resisting type. Insecure avoidant attachment is seen as conditionally pathological. There are 2 types of attachment disorders - reactive (avoidant type) and disinhibited (negative, neurotic type). These distortions of attachment lead to socio-psychological, personality disorders, make it difficult for the child to adapt to kindergarten and school. nine0017
Studies have shown that these manifestations of attachment disorders can be reversible and not accompanied by significant intellectual impairment.
Development of attachment in a foster family
All children, without exception, need to form a healthy emotional attachment to their parents. However, for children who came to a family from an orphanage, this process proceeds with great difficulties. The emotional relationship between a child and his biological parents is formed, among other things, thanks to a biological connection. There is no such connection between the adoptive parents and the child. However, this does not mean that a happy emotional attachment between them cannot be established. On the contrary, with certain efforts and great patience it is possible. To cope with the difficulties in the emotional development of an adopted child, it is necessary, first of all, to understand what these difficulties are. nine0017
Studies show that almost all children from the orphanage, even those who were adopted in infancy, have problems forming attachment to foster parents. This is because a secure attachment is formed when the caregiver is responsive to the child's needs in a timely manner, which creates a sense of stability and security for the child. In the event that the relationship with this person is interrupted, then the secure attachment relationship is destroyed. In an orphanage, a child is usually cared for by several people who pay more attention to regime moments than to actual needs. Adoptive parents, in turn, are strangers to the adopted child, and the establishment of a relationship of true affection is not established between them immediately, this process takes months and years. But parents can make it faster and more efficient. nine0017
The most favorable period for adoption is before the age of 6 months, since attachment has not yet formed, and the baby will not experience separation as acutely as an older child. In general, according to numerous adoption researchers, a healthy attachment is easier for children in a foster family to form if the child was securely attached to his birth parents (or substitute guardian). However, the history of the development of a pupil of an orphanage is not always prosperous until the moment of his adoption. Before being placed in an orphanage, children often grew up in dysfunctional families. nine0017
Among the reasons complicating the development of secure attachment of orphans, the researchers name the following:
- Separation from parents and placement in an orphanage.
- The situation of the death of a parent or person caring for him, especially violent.
- Violation of relationships in the family and the development of insecure attachment. A child with attachment disorders that arose in the parental family is able to attach to new parents with great difficulty, since he does not have a favorable experience of building relationships with an adult. nine0004
- Adoption of one child after the formation of attachment to the other parent or the eldest child in the family.
- Maternal prenatal use of alcohol and drugs.
- Violence experienced by children (physical, sexual or psychological). Children who have been abused at an early age may expect abuse in a new family and exhibit some of the already familiar strategies to deal with it. nine0003 Neuropsychiatric diseases of the mother.
- Drug or alcohol addiction of parents.
- Hospitalization of a parent or child resulting in the sudden separation of the child.
- Pedagogical neglect, neglect, ignoring the needs of the child.
Signs of an attachment disorder in a child's behavior
The risk of attachment disorders increases if the listed factors occur during the first two years of a person's life, and also when several factors are combined with each other. nine0017
The manifestations of attachment disorders can be identified by a number of signs.
- Reduced mood background. Lethargy. Alertness. Tearfulness.
- A persistent unwillingness to make contact with others, expressed in the fact that the child avoids eye contact, imperceptibly observes the adult, does not join in the activity proposed by the adult, and avoids tactile contact.
- Aggression and auto-aggression.
- The desire to draw attention to oneself by bad behavior, a demonstrative violation of the rules adopted in the house. nine0004
- Provocation of an adult to a vivid emotional reaction uncharacteristic for him (anger, loss of self-control). Having achieved such a reaction from an adult, the child can begin to behave well. For parents in this case, it is necessary to learn to feel the moment of provocation and use their own ways of coping with the situation (for example, count to 10 or tell the child that he is not ready to communicate now).
- Lack of distance in communication with adults. "Stickiness" to an adult. Orphanage children often show clinging to any new adult in their environment. nine0004
- Somatic disorders.
The willingness of the foster parent to give emotional warmth and accept the child as he is - are decisive for success in forming a child's attachment to a new family. Including a child in a new family means involving him in its rituals and customs, which may differ from his own. The quality of relationships with other family members and their willingness to accept the child and emotional openness are also a necessary factor in the formation of attachment. But the most important factor is integration of attachments - old and newly emerging, building a child's relationship to his past and parents. The family may not be able to cope with such a problem and the organized help of service specialists is required.
Thus, the condition for adaptation and socialization will be the placement of the child in a new family and the organization of an educational space that allows, in the process of interaction and mutual acceptance of the child and the family, to compensate for the negative consequences of injuries, form a new attachment and create conditions for the successful development of the child. nine0017
IV. The concept of "grief and loss" in the life of a child left without parental care.
To understand the essence of adaptation and to properly organize the work of teachers and foster carers, it is necessary to understand the dynamics of the state of a child who has experienced a break with his family. Let's consider stages of experiencing grief and loss :
- Shock and denial (the main feature of the child's behavior at this stage is that he unconsciously does not perceive the loss). nine0004
- Stage of anger.
- Depression and guilt (anxiety, melancholy, depression, guilt).
- The final stage is acceptance.
In general, during the period of adaptation to the foster family and getting used to the loss, the child's behavior is characterized by inconsistency and imbalance, the presence of strong feelings (which can be suppressed) and learning disorders. Usually adaptation occurs within a year. During this period, caregivers can provide significant assistance to the child, and this will serve as the "cement" that holds the new relationship together. However, if any of the above manifestations persist for a longer period, the help of specialists is needed. nine0017
The above description refers to the sphere of internal experiences of children who are faced with the problem of breaking close relationships and the need to form new attachments. At the same time, there is a clear dynamics in the process of building external relations with those people who take care of the child and become close to him, replacing parents to one degree or another.
In order to overcome the negative consequences of a break with parents, a child needs certainty and a sense of security, physical care, comfort. The basic sense of security, determined by the quality of attachment, determines the degree of adaptation of the child and affects the level of overall mental development (Bardyshevskaya, Maksimenko). The child's need for security is basic. Satisfaction or frustration of this need depends on the parenting strategy that the new mother chooses. An anxious child who does not feel safe tries to satisfy the need for safety by choosing a certain strategy of behavior, often inadequate to reality: hostility with the aim of retribution with a rejecting adult; over-obedience to return the love of a significant loved one, self-pity as a call for sympathy, idealization of oneself as compensation for feelings of inferiority. The result is a neuroticization of the child's needs. The behavioral features of a substitute adult during communication with a child determine the quality of the type of attachment that is being formed in him, and the formed attachment contributes to intensive and versatile mental development (Andreeva, Khaimovskaya, Maksimenko). New parents need to initiate positive interactions with the child, be the first to be attentive and interested in their affairs and feelings, ask questions, and express warmth and concern, even if the child appears indifferent or sullen. They need to be attentive to the memories of a child who needs to talk about what happened to him, about his family. It is necessary to preserve memorabilia and help in the establishment of life and study. Parents of children with insecure attachment show excessive interference in the child's actions (boundary violation), do not consider his own desires and needs, and do not respond to his requests (Grossman). nine0058 Violated maternal attitude , inadequate organization of communication with the child, manifestation of authoritarianism by the mother, rejection, overprotection or infantilization of the child contribute to the frustration of his needs. Excessive guardianship gives rise to infantilism and the child's inability to be independent, excessive demands - the child's self-doubt, emotional rejection - an increased level of anxiety, depression, aggression. The mother's attitude should be appropriate for the developmental needs of the child. E. Fromm defined as "heteronomic influence" the attitude of the mother, which is contrary to the natural growth of the child, in which the free, spontaneous expression of the desires and needs of the child is subject to various restrictions, which causes various mental pathologies. E.Fromm also studied the difference in the influences of a child's attachment to the mother and to the father at different stages of the child's development. They show that as they grow older, attachment to the mother loses its significance and after 6 years the child's need for father's love and guidance becomes actual. “The development from attachments centered around the mother to attachments centered around the father, and their gradual connection forms the basis of spiritual health and allows one to reach maturity. Deviations from the normal course of this development constitute the cause of various disturbances. nine0017
Thus, the strength and quality of attachments largely depend on the behavior of parents in relation to the child and on the quality of their attitude towards him (Ainsworth, Mukhamedrakhimov). This fully applies to substitute parents. The foster family must have experience in raising such a child, understand the patterns of child development and the consequences of losing attachment to blood parents, the influence of their own attitude towards the child on his development, i. e. be sufficiently prepared, in the future such a family will need the help of specialists. nine0017
How to behave with children? Psychologist's advice
When disturbing, frightening events occur or a situation of uncertainty arises, parents are often worried about questions: how to behave with a child correctly, how to tell him about what is happening and whether to tell him at all what should alert the child's behavior, and what, on the contrary, is normal.
In child psychology, it is customary to distinguish several age periods. Consider the features of interaction with children of preschool (3-7 years old) and primary school (7-11 years old) ages. nine0017
A few recommendations:
The greatest influence on the child is not even the situation itself, but the reaction to it of close adults who surround him. For a preschooler, such adults will be parents and those adult family members with whom communication takes place every day; For the younger student, the teacher also plays a significant role:
- Children are very sensitive to the emotional state of close, significant adults. When an adult is upset, anxious, scared, the child also experiences these emotions. If the child does not know the reason, then helplessness is added to fear and anxiety. Therefore, when you see a child's need to talk, do not ignore it. nine0004
Example: You are upset and need some time to recover. The child feels this and insistently asks the question “What happened?”
Wrong answer: "Nothing happened, go play (draw, do your homework)"
The correct answer is: “I’m a little upset (alarmed, sad) right now, because ..., let’s draw a robot now (do your math homework), and then we’ll go for a walk (we’ll have dinner).” nine0017
- When talking to your child, use simple, child-friendly phrases and expressions.
- Ask about the child's point of view. This will help to understand what worries, scares or worries him, and you can provide the necessary psychological support.
- Try to ensure that the positions of adults do not contradict each other. Putting a child in a situation of choice, you place an unbearable burden on him.
- Children very quickly adapt to the situation, BUT! Only on condition that the behavior of adults gives them such an opportunity. nine0004
Pay attention to information hygiene:
- Pay attention to what you watch or talk about with relatives, friends, acquaintances. Try not to see or hear what is not intended for him: emotional disputes with colorful examples, news releases with frightening details. Sometimes there is a feeling that the child does not pay attention to what is happening - this is an illusion! Based on the information obtained in this way, children often draw their own conclusions about what is happening, which are often the cause of children's fears. nine0004
- At primary school age, the information field of the child expands, it includes school friends, classmates, many at this age master communication on the Internet. Show interest in this area, ask about his friends and hobbies. A trusting relationship will help you spot trouble or danger.
- Talk to children about topics that concern them, do not limit yourself to the phrases “everything will be fine”, “this is an adult topic, you won’t understand”, etc. If adults do not give an answer to a question of interest to the child, he will find the answer in another source, which may be unreliable and even dangerous. nine0004
Pay attention to the behavior and mode of life of the child:
- Adults experience difficult moments, realizing, thinking over and discussing what is happening. Children have other ways. It is easier for a preschooler to cope with what is happening by playing or drawing it. Therefore, stories that frighten a child can be found in a game or drawings. For younger students, it is important to study, master new knowledge, so often children of this age try to learn more about what excites, frightens or disturbs. Do not prohibit children from these activities and do not blame them. The best strategy is discussion and cooperation. And if the behavior of the child is alarming, consult a child psychologist for advice. nine0004
- Organize your child's life by keeping the usual routine of the day as much as possible. The usual course of life, everyday affairs, the presence of a plan for the next day, week, month allow you to overcome the feeling of helplessness and anxiety, allow you to feel confident.
Do not neglect sports, communication, hobbies yourself and do not deprive this child. If something from the previous possibilities turned out to be unavailable, try to find a replacement. These activities allow you to replenish the resources and energy spent on experiences. nine0017
Seek professional help if necessary. You may need to consult a child psychologist if:
- The child's behavior has changed dramatically, these changes are persistent - they last several weeks or longer.