How to keep the father of your child away
Top 3 Improper Ways Parents Stop a Child From Seeing the Other Parent
Here are the top 3 improper ways a parent may try to stop a child from seeing the other parent
by B. Robert Farzad
Can a parent stop a child from seeing the other parent? Is it proper do so?
Find me two parents with a young child or children who are separating and you will likely find one parent asking these questions. Who asks this question? The parent whose parenting time is frustrated by the other parent.
What is the answer? The answer is usually no, a parent cannot stop a child from seeing the other parent unless a court order states otherwise. This question often comes up in the following situations.
- The parents (whether married or unmarried) are no longer together and the child resides with one of the parents. The parent with whom the child lives is limiting contact between the child and the other parent.
- The parents have an existing child custody and parenting time order. However, the child refuses to see one parent and the parent not seeing the child has reason to believe the other parent is encouraging this misbehavior.
- The parents have an existing court order, and a parent is violating the court order by interfering with the other parent's parenting time.
Let's get started.
P.S. If you like videos, we offer you one to watch below.
Be serious about parenting. This is not a game. Complaining about the other parent keeping the child from you may fall on deaf ears if you are not capable, ready and willing to spend quality time with your child.
Your Table of Contents for Topics We Cover
The following are the three main topics we cover.
- First, stopping a child from seeing the other parent when there is no court order.
- Second, stopping a child from seeing the other parent when a parent claims it is the "child's choice."
- Third and finally, stopping a child from seeing the other parent in violation of a court order.
Click on each image to jump ahead.
Play Video
Prefer to watch a video instead of or in addition to this article? You are in luck! Enjoy. For those with disabilities, here is a transcript of the video.Can a parent stop a child from seeing the other parent when there are no court orders?
We call this gate-keeping, and two types fit what we write about in this article.
Protective gate-keeping
Parents who have reasonable concerns about the other parent may engage in protective gate-keeping.
- They do stop a child from seeing the other parent but not because of nefarious reasons.
- They do so because of reasonable concerns grounded in facts.
The key to this is the facts.
A parent without a court order technically cannot stop a child from seeing the other parent. He or she may still have concerns regarding the following.
- Substance abuse,
- Lack of anger management (especially if it amounts to abuse), and
- Lack of parenting skills.
A parent who without reasonable justification stops a child from seeing the other parent often does so due to his or her own immaturity or nefarious intent. The gatekeeping results from the restrictive parent's obsession with control or simply unresolved anger against the other parent.
There is no perfect parent standard
What if the mother believes the father does not have her level of parenting skills? However, the father is otherwise capable of caring for the child without endangering the child. Is the mother's basis to stop a child from seeing the other parent unjustified? Yes, it is.
Through our extensive experience in child custody cases, we could probably give you over 50 examples of justified, protective gate-keeping and 50 more that were not.
Justification however still does not give a parent a legal basis to stop the child from seeing the other parent. The concerned parent should immediately seek appropriate child custody and visitation orders and bring his or her concerns to the court's attention.
The parent whose contact is unreasonably prevented or limited should not stand idly by and do nothing. If he or she does nothing, the parent may establish a status quo. The status quo may make it more difficult for the court to change it in the short term.
That parent should also seek immediate child custody and visitation orders.
What is a restrictive gate-keeper?
A restrictive gate-keeper is a parent who without justification prevents the child from seeing the other parent. The parent is usually scorned about the breakup and seeks his or her revenge by using a child as leverage to hurt the other parent.
This type of restrictive parent may also make false allegations of abuse or neglect against the other parent.
- Restrictive gate-keepers are not necessarily terrible parents.
- Despite their parenting skills, they have little respect for the other parent's role in the child's life.
Such parents engage in disparagement of the other parent or the other parent's family or friends to the child.
- Sometimes they do this directly to the child.
- Sometimes they ensure the child sees or overhears communication intended to disparage.
- They rarely co-parent without unreasonable conditions that satisfy their need for control.
Grandparents will sometimes become co-conspirators in the restrictive gate-keeping
We commonly see such parents defer to their parents (the child's grandparents) for help with the gate-keeping. The grandmother or grandfather then becomes a gate-keeping vehicle that assists the alienating parent throughout the process.
When a restrictive parent stops the child from seeing the other parent, court action becomes urgent. A gate-keeper is not a parent who reasonably believes they should limit contact. He or she is a parent who is often intent on destroying the other parent's relationship with the child.
- If the other parent does not take immediate court action, that parent empowers the restrictive parent to continue.
- The inaction often results in the bond between the other parent and the child to break.
This happens because the other parent spends limited or no time with his or her child.
When confronted with the restrictive gate-keeper, seeking joint custody is sometimes a mistake
Setting forth the restrictive gate-keeper's misconduct may justify asking the court for primary or even sole custody. Until the restrictive parent shows a willingness to co-parent and become reasonable, this may be the only reasonable option.
If the court does not grant your request, you will have at least set a precedent for it. Therefore, if you revisit it later, you may remind the court this was the concern you shared earlier, and it remains a concern.
All of this assumes you are the parent with the necessary parenting skills. It also assumes you have the time to dedicate to the child's care.
How can keeping a child from the other parent backfire if there are no court orders?
Just because there are no court orders does not mean a parent can frustrate the other parent's time with the child. The parent whose time was unreasonably frustrated has several options:
- The parent can ask the court for primary physical custody of the child or children. Frustration of parenting time is a factor the court takes into consideration when it makes custody orders. In extreme cases, especially those that involve abduction or concealing of the child, sole custody may be an appropriate request.
- The parent can ask the court to order the other parent into parenting or co-parenting classes. Some parents who keep a child from the other parent do so due to their own immaturity or failure to understand how such behavior actually hurts the child. Parenting or co-parenting classes can help.
- California Family Code 271 is designed to punish bad behavior by ordering a spouse or parent to pay the victimized parent's attorney fees if the unreasonable parent engaged in litigation misconduct. Keeping a child from the other parent, taking unreasonable positions during a custody case and forcing litigation and court proceedings are all sanctionable under section 271.
Reviews
Read What Our Clients Say
Results
Read Our Client's Victories
Profiles of Attorneys
Our High Skilled Advocates
We Hope You Are Enjoying This Article
As you continue to read this article, we wanted you to know the attorneys at our premier family law firm are a phone call or email away.
Click below if you want to call us. Our office hours are Monday through Friday, 8 AM to 5 PM.
The contact form you see will send us an email.
Now, back to the article!
Call Us
Email Us 24/7
Contact Us
Your First and Last Name *
Other Party's First and Last Name *
Your phone number *
Email Address *
The information you provide does not form any attorney-client relationship. Please only provide the information the form requests. We must first conduct a conflict check before we contact you. By contacting us through this form, you authorize us to communicate with you by phone or email and you agree to these terms and conditions.
I agree to the above terms and conditions *
Hidden website input
Can a parent stop a child from seeing the other parent by claiming it is the child's choice?
This part of the article is not about a situation where a child does not want to see the other parent for legitimate reasons. Such reasons include abuse or severe neglect. Instead, we write about those situations where a parent improperly influenced the child not to see the other parent.
To understand how and why this happens, a parent must understand parental alienation. Parental alienation is a common tactic by one parent who intends to significantly harm and even destroy the other parent's relationship with the child. From our article titled "What is Parental Alienation and What Can You Do About it?" (linked below), here is our definition.
"Alienation, by definition, means to isolate one thing from another. In the case of parental alienation, it means steps (often planned and malicious ones) a parent takes to isolate the child or children from the other parent through words and conduct and to create a division, estrangement and even hostility between the victimized parent and child."
There is little a parent can do to stop the alienation absent a court order. The way to stop it is for one of the following to occur.
- The alienating parent voluntarily changes his or her behavior, which rarely happens, or
- The victimized parent obtains a court order that takes custody away from the alienating parent.
We encourage you to read our articles on parental alienation as it will provide you with a proper strategy on how to document the misconduct. It will also teach you how to seek appropriate court orders to put an end to it.
We are skeptical of the "child's choice" claim some parents make. If the parent who is not seeing the child caused significant harm to the parent-child relationship, then a judge may see the child's choice as one that has evidentiary support.
However, absent that, there has to be another explanation and it is often parental alienation and interference with the parent-child relationship.
Children just do not, without a specific explanation, stop caring for and desiring to spend time with a parent. That effect has causes.
Additional articles you will enjoy
- Family Law Contempt Actions
- What is Parental Alienation?
- California Child Custody Laws
Can a parent stop a child from seeing the other parent by refusing to follow a court order?
The short answer is no; a parent cannot lawfully stop the child from seeing the other parent in such a circumstance.
- Court orders are not suggestions.
- They direct parents to comply with them.
- A parent who refuses to comply with a child custody order and stops a child from seeing the other parent violates the court order.
As I write this article, our law firm just won a contempt action, and the judge found the mother guilty of over 20 counts of contempt for her failure to abide by a child custody order.
Such action must be the measure of resolve by a parent who does not see his or her child as a result of the other parent's violations of an order.
To read more about contempt, check out our informative guide about family law contempt actions linked later in this article.
Are there situations a parent, despite a court order, should stop a child from seeing the other parent?
If there is child abuse or other conduct by the other parent that endangers the child's health or safety, a parent may take lawful steps to prevent the visitation.
However, absent extreme circumstances, a parent usually has the option of contacting the proper authorities including the police or child protective services. Also, if there is an immediate threat of harm to the child, a parent may seek emergency child custody relief.
To learn more about emergency court orders, read our article titled, Ex Parte Divorce and Ex Parte Custody Orders Are About Real Emergencies.
How can keeping a child from the other parent backfire if there are court orders?
We discussed contempt earlier and that is the most severe remedy against a parent who violates a court order. Contempt can carry fines, community service and even jail.
But in addition to a contempt action, keeping a child from the other parent in violation of a court order can also backfire by losing custody of the child.
A parent who violates a custody order does not act in the best interests of a child. Such a parent is either reckless or dangerous to a child's needs. Courts can and do take custody away from such parents depending on the severity of the misconduct.
Contact us for an affordable strategy session
Our attorneys do not have patience with a parent who unjustifiably interferes with the parent's parent-child relationship. Some of these malicious, interfering parents know they have no grounds to seek court orders to restrict or eliminate parenting time so they engage in self help. They count on the fact the victimized parent will not act.
Unfortunately, many times, the malicious parent is right. Too many fathers and mothers do not take these issues seriously enough and lose out on quality time with their children.
It takes courage to take action.
Through that courage and action, you can stop a parent's unlawful or improper interference.
When you have the courage, what do you do? You contact us.
There is no substitute for legal advice from and representation by an experienced California family law attorney.
We believe good men and women deserve great family law representation. Contact us for an affordable strategy session.
Your Strategy Session
About your strategy session
Southern California Offices
Locations
Our Services and Fees
Frequently asked questions
Strategy sessions are designed for the serious parent. We know how important your children are to you. Their health, safety and best interests are our priority.
Was this article helpful to you?
Yes
No
Thank you, we appreciate your feedback!
How Can a Suicidal Parent Lose Custody?
by B. Robert Farzad
How to File a Motion for Drug Testing Against a Drug Addicted Parent
by B. Robert Farzad
OurFamilyWizard versus TalkingParents: Which App is Right for You?
by B. Robert Farzad
Cohabitation and Alimony in California
by Yvette Ochoa
More Publications
7 Ways To Lose Custody of Your Child: Moms and Dads
Parents often wonder how a mother can lose custody of her child. The truth is mothers can lose custody in the same way as fathers.
It's a common misconception that family courts favor mothers, when in fact, no state has laws favoring mothers in custody decisions. Many states actually have laws that prohibit family court judges from considering either parent's gender.
Custody cases in all states are decided based on the child's best interests.
Contrary to popular belief then, a mother — just like a father — can lose custody if the court decides that it's best for the child.
Custody X Change is software that creates parenting plans and custody schedules.
Make My Schedule and Plan Now
It's generally considered best for both parents to be involved in their child's upbringing. When a parent loses custody, judges still typically order some limited parenting time for them, such as supervised visitation.
Family courts often set conditions to allow the restricted parent to eventually earn unrestricted or additional time with the child. For example, if a mother loses custody for drug abuse and has supervised visitation, the court may allow her to have unsupervised visits after completing addiction treatment and participating in drug testing.
How a mother or father can lose custody
In all states, the court's primary concern is the child's physical safety and caretaking needs. Family courts also ensure that children have stable homes and are secure with both parents.
If a mother or father poses a risk to their child's safety or security, the other parent can ask the court to order sole physical custody to restrict the unsafe parent's time with the child and sole legal custody to limit their role in making decisions about the child.
1. Abusing or neglecting the child
If a parent physically abuses or neglects their child, courts typically award sole custody to the other parent.
Child abuse is defined as any non-accidental physical harm to a child caused by a parent or caregiver. It includes hitting, punching, whipping, burning, hair pulling, shoving, throwing, choking and any other action that causes physical injury. Physical discipline (e.g., spanking) is not considered abuse if it does not injure the child. (However, experts recommend non-physical discipline.)
Sexual abuse occurs when a parent or caregiver uses a child for sexual purposes or involves the child in sexual acts. It also occurs when an older or more powerful child uses a younger child for sexual acts. Parents who sexually abuse their child or knowingly put them at risk of sexual abuse typically lose custody and, often, parental rights.
Emotional abuse includes not offering affection, shaming the child, telling them they're unwanted, yelling at them and keeping them isolated from others. Courts consider emotional and psychological abuse when determining custody, especially if a parent has mental health issues that negatively impact their parenting (e.g., if a parent is a narcissist).
Neglect is a form of abuse in which a parent fails to meet the child's care needs. Physical neglect includes not caring for the child's hygiene and not providing adequate shelter, food or clothing.
Leaving a child alone or with inadequate or dangerous caregivers is also considered neglect. Educational neglect occurs when a parent doesn't enroll the child in school, allows them to miss a lot of school or ignores their special education needs. Medical neglect is failure to ensure the child receives necessary or recommended medical care.
2. Using alcohol or drugs irresponsibly
If a parent's alcohol or drug use impacts the child, or if a parent has untreated alcohol or drug addiction, courts will most likely restrict their parenting time to supervised visitation. Illegal drug use, even if the parent hasn't been convicted of a drug crime, can also cause a parent to lose custody.
Additionally, many states have laws addressing child custody and convictions for driving under the influence (DUI). In Arizona, for example, the court can deny or restrict parenting time for a parent who has a DUI conviction within 12 months of the custody dispute.
If a parent who formerly abused alcohol or drugs has received treatment and is otherwise a safe parent, courts will most likely not restrict their custody, especially if they've been in recovery for a significant amount of time. The court may require drug testing or evidence of ongoing treatment.
How cannabis use impacts custody depends on the state's laws and if the parent's use affects the child. Like moderate and safe alcohol use, the court may not consider it a risk if the parent uses it legally, safely (e.g., no driving under the influence) and only when they're not around the child.
However, if the parent uses cannabis illegally or endangers the child through their use, the court may limit their custody. It's also important to remember that cannabis is still illegal under federal law, even in states that have legalized. Depending on the court and judge, even legal recreational use could be viewed as criminal activity that endangers the child.
3. Abducting the child
Parent–child abduction — also called parental kidnapping and custodial interference — is a crime that occurs when a parent keeps the child from the other parent with the intent of interfering with that parent's custodial rights.
When this happens, the parent who abducted the child often loses custody, especially if they took the child over state lines or to another country, or if they caused the child psychological or physical harm.
However, if the victim keeps the child away from the other parent in order to protect themself or the child from abuse, the court may not consider it a crime or hold it against them in custody decisions.
4. Disobeying court orders
Custody orders — often issued in the form of a parenting plan and a parenting time schedule — are legal mandates that both parents must follow. Depending on the number and severity of the violations, disobeying court orders can result in loss of custody and even criminal charges.
For example, repeatedly being very late to drop off the child is not only disobeying court orders, it can be considered custodial interference or parental kidnapping, which are crimes.
Violations prevent effective co-parenting and can negatively impact the child, so courts take them seriously and often limit the custody of the violating parent.
Disobeying child support orders, however, is typically not grounds for losing custody. A parent who fails to pay child support may face civil or criminal charges, but courts do not take away their parenting time. Additionally, the other must still follow the court orders, including the parenting schedule.
5. Interfering in the child's relationship with the other parent
Family courts emphasize the importance of children having ongoing, healthy relationships with both parents. This is why joint custody is the most common arrangement. It's also why a parent who tries to minimize the other parent's role in the child's life without a reasonable cause (e.g., protecting the child's safety) may lose custody.
In addition to preventing the child from seeing the other parent, interfering with the child's relationship with the other parent includes badmouthing them to or in front of the child, lying about them and discouraging the child from wanting to spend time with them.
Parental alienation is a severe form of interference in which a parent deliberately manipulates their child to turn against the other parent. There are currently no state laws that specifically address parental alienation, but many child custody experts consider it abuse. Family court judges often rule against the alienating parent and may order individual or family counseling.
6. Lying to the court
Lying in court paperwork or to the judge can also impact custody. While lying to the court (perjury) is a crime, family courts rarely pursue charges against a parent for lying. Instead, judges consider the dishonesty evidence that the parent won't support the child's relationship with the other parent or co-parent effectively. In these situations, judges often rule in favor of the other parent.
In particular, courts do not look favorably on parents who lie about child abuse or domestic violence. Many states, including California, Florida and New York, have laws that empower judges to restrict custody for a parent who knowingly makes false abuse allegations.
7. Generally putting the child at risk
Other behaviors and parenting issues that put the child's physical and emotional well-being at risk can also cause a parent to lose custody.
Convictions for crimes or evidence of criminal activity, especially if the crimes are violent or if the victim was a child, typically cause a parent to lose custody.
When evaluating possible risks to children, courts also consider who lives in each parent's home and who spends time around the child. For example, if a parent's romantic partner has a criminal record or abuses drugs, judges often consider this a risk to the child and limit that parent's custody.
Irresponsible parenting — e.g., having lax rules, encouraging reckless behavior, not monitoring media content — can also be used as evidence that a parent isn't adequately caring for their child. If the irresponsible parent puts the child at significant physical, emotional or psychological risk, courts may limit their custody and order them to complete parenting classes.
Unemployment in and of itself will not cause a parent to lose custody. However, if a parent is unable to financially care for their child and issues of neglect arise, a judge may award custody to the more financially-stable parent. A parent who pays child support must still make payments if they lose their job, but they can ask the court to modify their child support order when they have an involuntary job loss.
Child custody evaluations
When the child's saftey is a concern, disputed cases typically include a custody evaluation, in which a court-ordered expert (often a mental health professional) evaluates parents' ability to adequately care for their child.
The evaluator reviews the family's records and interviews the parents. Often, they also interview the child and others who know the family. The evaluator writes a report for the judge that summarizes everything and makes custody recommendations. Judges don't always order what the evaluator recommends, but they typically give the reports great weight.
Either parent can request an evaluation, and judges often order them of their own accord when they need more information. In many courts, custody evaluations are automatic if child abuse is alleged or suspected. Courts may also appoint a guardian ad litem to investigate the family and represent the child's best interests in court.
Modifying orders
Either parent can ask the court to modify existing custody orders and request sole custody. If the child is in immediate physical danger, courts can issue an emergency order to protect them from the unsafe parent.
Remember that family courts don't take what parents say at face value — they require proof (evidence) of every claim made in court paperwork and proceedings. In addition to reports from custody evaluators, common custody evidence includes photos, emails, text messages, social media posts, family calendars and official records (e.g., medical, school, criminal, child protective services).
The tools you need to seek custody
The Custody X Change app has many features that help you organize the evidence you need so you can seek custody and help secure your child's safety.
- Create a detailed parenting plan that spells out every aspect of co-parenting in airtight legal language and shows the judge your competency.
- Make a custom parenting time schedule that meets your child's needs and supports their relationship with the other parent.
- Keep a custody journal to electronically organize evidence, document incidents and keep a record of parenting plan violations.
- Track actual parenting time and get reports showing parenting time violations.
- Use the secure messaging center to keep an accurate record of your conversations with the other parent.
- Link your account to your lawyer's and print your journal, reports and messages so you can submit them to the court as evidence.
Use Custody X Change to stay organized and get what's best for your child.
Custody X Change is software that creates parenting plans and custody schedules.
Make My Schedule and Plan Now
Custody X Change is software that creates parenting plans and custody schedules.
Make My PlanHow to deal with a tyrant in the family | Chita.ru
Photo: http://psikolojiakademi.com
Share
On the afternoon of April 30, a resident of Chita locked himself in an apartment on Ukrainsky Boulevard and held his three-year-old son hostage for several hours until 1:00 the next day. The man had a weapon. The mother of the child told the news agency "Chita.Ru" about what preceded the tragedy.
During the first press approach, which was given by the assistant to the head of the investigation department, the phrase was heard that due to the age of three, the child "did not adequately assess the situation." We decided to find out from psychologists what such cases are fraught with for children and how mothers who find themselves in abusive relationships should behave.
In an abusive relationship, one partner violates the personal boundaries of the other, humiliates, allows cruelty in communication and actions in order to suppress the will of the victim. In this type of relationship, the victim and the aggressor do not change places; for a number of reasons, the victim cannot get out of this relationship.
Tatyana Kuzmina, a medical psychologist at the Medlyuksik Children's Center, believes that the age of three could hardly protect a child from psychological trauma.
- It all depends on how the situation [developed]. It’s impossible to say for sure, but psychologists who work with such psychological trauma say that the younger the child, the stronger the psychological trauma, and even more serious consequences are possible.
- What is the effect of such an experience on a child?
- [In such cases] parents make a mistake [if] they do not seek help because [the child] does not have obvious manifestations. Changes can appear much later, and the child himself cannot cope with this. What symptoms, disturbances in a consequence can be shown? Regression - a return in development to earlier stages: he may begin to talk and behave like a smaller one, self-service skills may be violated.
If a child is normal and already speaks well at the age of 3, he can become uncommunicative, withdrawn, not talking at all, with strangers - from the word at all. He may have fears, sleep disturbances, he may be in an anxiety-depressive state or a state with a reduced emotional background. All these symptoms often begin to appear after such traumatic situations. And, perhaps not immediately - gradually. And recovery occurs not earlier than in a year.
- Is it necessary to somehow build communication with the child in a special way after such an incident?
- In general, in such situations, children react to the mother's emotional state: how she felt at that moment, how she behaved. As a psychologist from work experience, [I will say]: if dad has always been like this, with [similar] manifestations, then this is a familiar picture for a child. For him, more important is how mother reacted to this situation, how worried she was, anxious, whether her behavior differed from her usual - this moment makes a big impression.
To restore the psyche, the child needs attention, care, care, return to a comfortable state, positive emotions, play. And if he speaks well, it makes sense to listen to what he says. Maybe at first he will not tell, but then he will still begin to return to this situation. Sometimes children start playing these events. That is, you don’t need to try to switch them and replace them with something, but give the opportunity to react to this whole situation, lose it, speak it out.
- The ex-wife of the accused told that she was afraid of her husband and he threatened her.
- This is clearly a deviation from the norm, from some kind of normal family foundations. Probably, this is not the atmosphere in which you can bring up a full-fledged, confident, successful person. Parents educate their children by their behavior, [everything that he saw in the family,] the child will carry on.
- What advice can you give to women in this relationship? How to minimize the risk to the child?
- As I said, the child reacts to the mother. If a mother makes a choice for herself that this is the relationship she needs, she must control her behavior. When a woman demonstrates that she is unhappy and everything is bad, how can this be minimized? The child sees it, he lives in it. It is, of course, difficult. If a mother makes such a choice, she must demonstrate that everything is in order, everything is fine. Or look for forms of change [of the situation], look for an acceptable path for yourself. Of course, a child is happy in a family where parents are happy. You can't talk about happiness, you can only show it.
- Is it possible to recognize the moment before some radical action by the abuser? It is clear that all this is individual, but are there any patterns that indicate that the situation is reaching a peak?
- In any case, a sign that some actions may occur are words, pronunciation of intentions. If a man says that such actions are possible, there is no guarantee that this will not lead to action. Already from the very beginning he prepares and admits the possibilities of certain events. Therefore, one should not count on chance, [and think] that this will never happen. This is the first moment. The second moment is when this [voicing] is accompanied by moments of physical aggression. [Then] such situations are predictable to some extent.
- How can a child build relationships with an abusive father in the future?
- In any case, the child will need psychological help. Accept this situation, reformat it, because he has to live with it. It is important how, in general, information [about the father] is given to him, so as not to live later in the state of the victim. This is important for the self-esteem of the child, for his future. One part of the child is the mother, the other is the father. They cannot be bad a priori. For a person to be happy, some moments must be worked out and some kind of balance found.
Olga Sokolova, clinical psychologist at the Academy of Health, explains that a child may not really be aware of the danger that threatens him.
- He may be scared, offended, he may have desires, but he hardly assessed what happened to him [precisely as] a threat to life and health. Until the age of 3, a child by and large does not understand the danger and cannot adequately assess it. If this is his father, I am now fantasizing (about the specific situation with the Dokins) , then perhaps they had a good relationship and “kept the child” - this, excuse me, is a trick of journalists. Maybe he turned on cartoons for him or closed him in a room with toys? He created some conditions so that the child, according to the father, was safe.
- Does a child who has encountered such manipulation by a parent, in any case, need to turn to psychologists? Or is relative comfort somehow able to mitigate the trauma?
- This is a long-term situation, and she can shoot in adulthood. It can become psychotraumatic, [especially] if it is given an emotional coloring.
- If an abusive relationship lasts for several years, how realistic is it for a woman to get out of this scenario on her own?
- In this case, the girl definitely needs to go to a psychologist. We have a crisis center for women who find themselves in a difficult life situation in Beregina. There is free psychological help by phone [support], you can call the round-the-clock line. Of course, in order to decide to change the situation, one needs both strength and emotional and financial resources.
- Why do women wait to the last? Can it be that the victims justify their fear and decision to stay with the aggressor by caring for the child?
- Here you can judge differently. [Really important for a child] is the educational attitude of both parents. Perhaps a woman has working conditions, and she needs her to come and have a husband at home. To meet the child from the kindergarten. There can be many “profitable” moments.
Sometimes women say “my grandmothers lived like that, my mother lived” and endure. To understand what is happening with a partner, and how normal his behavior is, you can go to a psychologist and describe the symptoms. And the specialist will tell you whether this is the norm or a pathology. And if they tell you that this is a pathology, that he will not change and his behavior will progress, there is nothing to catch in such a relationship. And while alive and safe, [you need to leave], you need to take care of yourself and your child.
- When children grow up in such families, do they have a chance to build normal relationships in the future without the help of psychotherapists?
- Relationships with parents leave an imprint on our professional success, on personal events, we carry the scenario of family relations into our family. It’s good if we evaluate and say: “I won’t have such a family. I know what kind of family I want to build, and I know how to do it.” From the point of view of the environment, it may seem that the marriage is not happy, but the couple will be comfortable.
Our roles have also changed. If earlier a man ran after a mammoth and got food, and a woman was the keeper of the hearth, now women drive rather big cars and run after a mammoth themselves. And for some it will seem like the wrong relationship, but for some it will be comfortable.
Nowhere is it written what is right and what is wrong. If a person is unhappy in a relationship, he looks for options on how to make them happy. And he finds opportunities.
- How can harm to the child be minimized in such a relationship?
- Food, sleep, toys, developmental environment, love are very important for a child.
- That is, if this is and is love, then the mother can somehow compensate for the aggression of the father?
- Of course. There is a film "Temporary difficulties". Relations in the family were not comfortable for the child, but in the end he grew up to be a fairly healthy person.
- Have you ever had cases when abusive marriages were somehow rehabilitated?
- I work both with families and individually with women in similar situations. My clear position is to save the family only if there is no threat to life and health. If this threat exists, then definitely don't store . If the first time was physical abuse, the second, the woman should ask herself the question: “What do I get in this relationship? Am I happy?
A psychologist is that specialist to whom no one says: "You know, I'm so happy." If a woman came with a ready desire to divorce, then the psychologist begins to investigate whether this is really so. And what does her request sound like? This is one side. The other is when both come to maintain and build other relationships. There are relationship crises, as well as age-related ones. The feeling of falling in love passes, and attraction, and passion, and then you need to build a family on new values, have common plans and common goals.
There are places in Chita where women can turn for help in difficult situations. On the basis of the perinatal center at Kokhansky, 16, in Chita, there is a service of medical and social assistance. Calls are accepted at 8-924-509-08-93 from 8. 00 to 16.00.
The Bereginya Center at 7a Truda Street helps women, families and children. Number: 8 (3022) 25-32-11.
You can also get a qualified consultation free of charge at the crisis center of the Kandinsky Regional Psychiatric Hospital, which is located on Okruzhny proezd, 3. You can come here anonymously. In total, the center accepts 10 specialists. The entry here is scheduled for two weeks in advance, but at the same time, a helpline is working, where it is easy to get through and get emergency help: 40-14-83 . And you can sign up for a face-to-face appointment by phone: +7 (914) 800-54-96.
If you have the opportunity to go to paid therapy, see our review of prices for the services of psychotherapists and psychologists in specialized centers in Chita.
Experts told how to protect your child from strangers – Moscow 24, 09/06/2022
Cases when children obediently go somewhere with strangers are not uncommon. Unfortunately, such situations often end in sad consequences. We tell how parents can protect their child from strangers.
Get ready to work
Photo: depositphotos/annadanilkova
Many parents believe that their children will not leave with strangers. But at the same time, adults cannot explain what their confidence is based on, security expert Katerina Sobkalova told Moscow.
"Just telling a child 100 times: 'You can't go away with strangers' will not make him safe. You have to work with children: give them time, not shout and forbid, but find the strength in yourself to talk calmly, to explain and even work out in advance what to do in dangerous situations. It is difficult, but this is the only way to achieve something," she warned.
Psychologist Elena Buryevaya also noted that parents tend to perceive themselves and their children as a whole and think: if they understand some things, then they are obvious to their son or daughter.
But a child is a separate person, and he does not know how everything works in the world. Therefore, he must be taught absolutely everything, including the rules by which he can live quite safely and comfortably.
It is necessary to train from about one year of age. Every time, walking with the baby on the playground, start explaining to him: he must first ask you if it is possible or not, if someone wants to give him something, give him, show him, or he decided to go somewhere, even very close, from the site.
Elena Buryeva
child psychologist
Asking permission from adults is a very important safety rule. If you introduce it from a very early age, it will become the norm for the child. He will continue to follow it on the machine, even when he starts walking on his own. This will be taken for granted, and not cause protest and questions about why the child is obliged to report to the parents.
Talk about personal boundaries
Photo: depositphotos/expsycholog.gmail.com
From the age of three, it is important to introduce a child to social circles and talk about personal boundaries. You can draw them directly on the floor or on the pavement with chalk.
Draw the first circle around the child's legs. Explain that he is in the center of his life - in it the baby is the most important. The thoughts and actions of the child also belong only to him, the psychologist explained.
In addition, no one can touch or kiss the baby without permission. Just like he has no right to touch someone who does not want to.
Ask the child to extend their arm and take a little more than half of it into the next circle. He is the closest, his family. Usually it is only mom, dad, brother, sister, sometimes grandparents.
Be sure to tell them that in every family there are secrets and secrets that cannot be told to anyone, even if they ask. For example, about when parents leave and return home, how the apartment opens, whether the baby is left alone, and so on.
Friends in the next circle. The palm of the child will fall into it, and this means that they are still close. You can’t discuss family secrets with them, but you can hug if they don’t mind.
Then draw a circle - acquaintances. It includes neighbors, a friend's mother, and so on. The child's palm no longer reaches this circle, which means that they must be restrained with them. We see these people very often, we greet them, we can ask how things are going. But we do not tell them secrets and do not hug them.
Another circle - professions. Tell your child who the police officers, rescuers of the Ministry of Emergency Situations, doctors are. Explain that, despite the rule "my body is my business," if trouble happened and you need help, you need to trust these specialists. Their mission is to save the lives and health of others.
Elena Buryevaya
child psychologist
In the last circle we have strangers, there are a lot of them. But you shouldn't scare your child. It is better to say that most likely they are all good. However, there are among them those who can hurt and hurt others. It is very difficult to recognize them, because most often they do not look like villains. Therefore, the child does not need to communicate with strangers without adults from the "family" circle.
The specialist reminded parents to be careful not to allow inconsistency in safety rules.
"Here's a common situation for you: adults explain to a child that it is dangerous to leave with strangers, and then they take him to an entertainment center and immediately leave him with a complete stranger - an animator. The kid no longer understands how the rules he was told about work in life,” says the psychologist.
In this particular case, it is important to give the child time. He must see: the parents met with the animator and made sure that the baby would be safe. Only after that they were allowed to go with an employee of the entertainment center.
Make algorithms of actions
Photo: depositphotos/kurgu128.mail.ru
The child should have not only a clear division into "friends and foes" adults, but also an understanding of which category and how to act safely for themselves, noted Sobkalov.
Our own are close people, there are very few of them. They are engaged in the upbringing of the child, they are trusted by the parents. You can help your own, it is safe to leave with them and take treats from them.
Do not include family friends, mother's best friend, and so on in the "friends" category. These people are from the category "familiar, but strangers." You can help them or leave with them, only with the permission of "their own".
Katerina Sobkalova
security expert
A child has the right not to help strangers, and the parent must give him permission to do so. It is important to speak clearly with the baby: if someone from strangers approached him and asked him to hold the car door, carry the bags to the bench, help get the kitten that ran away, and so on, then he has the right to answer to "ask another adult" and leave .
The child should know the rule that children are not usually asked for help.
Learn to assess situations
Another important skill that parents should teach their children is to distinguish between dangerous and safe situations. This should become a habit for them.
"You won't be able to teach this if you just name different situations. It's better to ask questions: "If you come close to the barbecue, is it dangerous?", "And if a stranger offers you something to drink?" Then ask to clarify why this is so what can happen and how to act to stay safe. Help him answer, "Sobkalova advised.
Gradually, the child will learn to evaluate situations and behave correctly in them. Grandmother on the street will offer a candy, he will simply refuse and go for a walk further. An unfamiliar girl will drive up in a car, open the trunk and ask for help to carry the boxes to the third floor. The child realizes that the situation can be dangerous, it is necessary to refuse and increase the distance.
If a friend asks for help - a friend's mother, a father's colleague, a coach from the last section, and so on - the child will automatically say: "Now I will call my parents and warn them. " Even if a person had bad thoughts, he will understand that adults are aware of the whereabouts of the baby.
Katerina Sobkalova
security expert
The ability to assess the situation is useful for a child not only in terms of communicating with strangers, but also in other cases. For example, when he wants to play with knives, matches or scissors, when he is called to the garages, they offer him something to eat or drink.
Let me say "no"
Photo: depositphotos/belchonock
The main reason why children leave with strange adults is that they simply cannot refuse them.
"Firstly, there is an age peculiarity. A child under eight years old has all the adults in authority. With this in mind, parents should not let their children go out alone. They can walk without their parents, but then they must be in the company of their peers," Buryevaya warned .
It is also about education. In our society, it is customary from childhood to repeat to a person like a mantra: "don't shout, be quiet, behave yourself. " Is it any wonder then that a child obediently fulfills such requests of a stranger.
In a moment of danger, the child needs the emotion of anger. But it is her parents who most often suppress in their children, categorically forbidding them to scream and get angry.
The emotion of anger is the main vital energy, power, indicator of violation of boundaries. By suppressing this emotion, we take away from the child a sense of his own power. He becomes unsure of himself, anxious, controllable. If he is offered to go somewhere, he will not be able to say no.
Elena Buryeva
child psychologist
In order not to suppress the child's emotions, do not ask him to stop, shut up, calm down, no matter how uncomfortable and unpleasant he behaves. The best option is to use the reflection technique. To do this, you just need to voice the emotions that he is probably experiencing to the baby: “You are screaming because you are scared or you just don’t like it. ”
Parents need to be patient, because this technique will not help the child to calm down, but will give him the opportunity to live emotions, and they will not be suppressed.
A baby is born with the ability to draw attention to itself in times of danger. The task of the parents is not to drown her out. Do not ask to be silent when he screams, but calmly say: "I can hear you. Are you attracting my attention?"
Parents have to choose. Or now talk a lot with the child and explain everything, so that later he would be independent and self-sufficient. Or simply force, forbid, and then there will always be a risk that he will not be able to assess the dangerous situation, refuse and protect himself.
Katerina Sobkalova
security expert
A child can say "no" in society when he has the right to an opinion in the family. If a student does not do his homework, we usually shout and force him. But it’s better to say that he has the right to refuse, while let him give three arguments why he doesn’t want to do his homework.